This is our City: Kevin De Bruyne Is David Silva's Heir, Nasri Deserves More Respect Than He Gets From Outsiders

31 August 2015

Kevin De Bruyne Is David Silva's Heir, Nasri Deserves More Respect Than He Gets From Outsiders



With the arrival of Kevin De Bruyne many have questioned where he will fit in and whether Manchester really need the Bundesliga's best player last season. It's made for some pretty bland reading, seems like the some authors of ignorant articles have only just started paying attention to City since 2015. Questioning where Manchester's goals are going to come from if our Sergio Aguero ends up injured?, forgive me but haven't we been the highest goal scoring club in the country for at least 3 seasons now?

As well as that pundits have been equally baffled and mesmerised  at our transfer power and player selection, all the talk has been about where Kevin De Bruyne will fit in and whether or not Manchester needs him. Some have naively claimed De Bruyne will have problems getting game time, stating with Navas being on form? (Is he?) and with Sterling and Silva taking the Premier League by storm that it looks like De Bruyne will end up on the bench for now.

To me it's all just ignorant and plain stupid, none of them have actually spent the time to analyse each player and compare, or researched where the players strengths and weaknesses compare. None of them have picked up on the real reason why Manchester have signed De Bruyne. For Instance:

David Silva is 29 but still in the form of his life and he has no defensive weakness, he can operate across the attacking midfield or as a second forward. So it's fair to say his position at center forward is safe, Merlin is in the form of his career and turning opposing defences inside out.

Samir Nasri is 28 can also play any position across the attacking midfield, however his strongest position is on the left wing. He is defensively weak but his finishing is OK.

Jesus Navas is 29 and only operates as an attacking Right Winger, he's defensively weak. His crossing and speed is his only positive contribution, he isn't strong in the air and his ability to finish is average. While he's been a positive recently after the arrival of Sterling, I feel underwhelmed by Navas prior to Sterling's arrival.

Raheem Sterling is 20 so still very young and has a lot of improving to do, he operates as a Left Winger but can also play across the attacking midfield and as a forward. It's quite exciting to see at aged 20 he's already as good as most of the other title contenders first eleven and could walk into any of their teams easily. Like Silva, his finishing is good, but he's way off being on the level of David Silva obviously. He's never going to be strong in the air due to his frame but he needs to improve on his crossing as a priority, his defensive contribution is OK but can also improve.

Now for the comparisons:

De Bruyne is only 24 compared to Navas 29, Silva 29 and Nasri 28.
De Bruyne can play in any attacking midfield position like Silva, Nasri or Sterling.
De Bruyne is stronger in Left Centre Midfield but can operate on the Left or Right like Sterling.
De Bruyne is Defensively weak as is Nasri and Navas but has youth on his side to improve.
De Bruyne is more like David Silva than any of the other three players City have.
De Bruyne is a better attacking player than Nasri, Navas or Sterling although Sterling has plenty of time to improve. He has more to his game as he's stronger at Shooting from range, Through Balls, Finishing and Set Piece taking, while being equally as good as or better in the other attacking area's.

So who is under threat from De Bruyne? and who was he really bought in to replace?

I believe he's the long term Heir to David Silva although currently no threat, he will add adequate cover for Silva.

I believe he's currently only a threat to Nasri and Navas as both De Bruyne and Sterling can operate of both wings, while Nasri can also operate in those positions he doesn't have youth on his side.

De Bruyne will for the time being compete with Navas.

Our club are plugging the gap between our first team and our academy, our under 18's are looking very promising indeed but I believe only a handful of our under 21's will make the grade. I believe in the next 5 years we will start to see the fruits of our labour.

Kevin and Raheem will have no fixed position and this will cause havoc and mayhem for our enemies with David Silva controlling the show backed up by two holding midfielders. It would be sad to see Nasri leave as he has given us a lot to be thankful for, the reason Arsenal fans are so so bitter about him is because they know he was a bigger loss than they let on. While we are a forward down I do think it would be crazy to let him leave this season but if a nice little bid came in at his age then it would be hard to turn down I guess. With all due respect to Navas he has been a good servant to our club over the two years he's been with us, while it wouldn't be an issue if he stuck around a nice offer coming in would also be hard to turn down, after all for Manchester no player is irreplaceable other than Hart, Silva and Aguero.

Final thought, it's always weighed heavy on my mind how we would ever cover and eventually replace Silva, it's a relief seeing our club wrap up a player capable of covering and eventually replacing our miracle boy Merlin aka David Silva seemed almost impossible until now. Under Silva's wing I believe De Bruyne will end up just as good if not better, what do you think?

Whether Samir Nasri leave's us or not, I will be thankful and happy. He's still a valuable player and has much to offer.





3 comments:

  1. Navas defensively week? Behave!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous31/8/15

    Samir and Edin have both been good servants of the club and though Edin has left, He never made a fuss of anything, ideal player and so is Samir. I think David is the best we have seen since Gorgi but he receives a lot of knocks and we will need Samir to help us when he is out injured. Silva, Yaya and Samir are a deadly combo with aguero and sterling its going to be even more dangerous. Kevin will send Navas home but Navas has helped us a lot too. City are a family and we all care about each other

    ReplyDelete

Abusive or inappropriate comments will not be published, please keep it appropriate.